Men
2024 - Noah Tobin, Wilmington 
2023 - Simon Heys, Wilmington
2022 - Alex Phillip, John Carroll
2021 - Alex Phillip, John Carroll
2020 - Did not compete
2019 - Chase Hampton, Otterbein
2018 - Ian McVey, Ohio Northern
2017 - Ian McVey, Ohio Northern
2016 - Ian McVey, Ohio Northern
2015 - Alex Wilson, Mount Union
2014 - Alex Wilson, Mount Union
2013 - Dan McGeary, Mount Union
2012 - Caleb Muller, Marietta
2011 - Ken Janosko, Baldwin Wallace
2010 - Ty Griffin, Mount Union
2009 - Alan Bowsher, Ohio Northern
2008 - Jimmy O`Brien, Ohio Northern
2007 - Jimmy O`Brien, Ohio Northern
2006 - Scott Lasch, Heidelberg
2005 - Mike Sawicki, Otterbein
2004 - Mike Sawicki, Otterbein
2003 - Chris Paulett, Mount Union
2002 - Bryan Less, Mount Union
2001 - Mark Prejsnar, Mount Union
2000 - Tim Budic, Baldwin Wallace
1999 - Troy Rathge, Otterbein

Women
2024 - Faith Duncan,Wilmington 
2023 - Hope Murphy, Baldwin Wallace
2022 - Macy McAdams, Muskingum
2021 - Hope Murphy, Baldwin Wallace
2020 - Did not compete
2019 - Kelly Brennan, Baldwin Wallace
2018 - Claire Lamb, Otterbein
2017 - Claire Lamb, Otterbein
2016 - Claire Lamb, Otterbein
2015 - Claire Lamb, Otterbein
2014 - Catie Campbell, Mount Union
2013 - Sohpie Goobic, Heidelberg
2012 - Alison Steinbrunner, Ohio Northern
2011 - Alison Steinbrunner, Ohio Northern
2010 - Alison Steinbrunner, Ohio Northern; Kim Chinn, Baldwin Wallace
2009 - Alison Steinbrunner, Ohio Northern
2008 - D`Arcy Hlavin, Baldwin Wallace
2007 - Nicole Reese, Otterbein; Lindsay Brickner, Baldwin Wallace
2006 - Melinda Keesee, Otterbein
2005 - Ellie Fernandez, John Carroll
2004 - Shannon McConville, John Carroll
2003 - Shannon McConville, John Carroll
2002 - Jessica Textoris, Baldwin Wallace
2001 - Hannah Purdy, Baldwin Wallace
2000 - Hannah Purdy, Baldwin Wallace
1999 - Hannah Purdy, Baldwin Wallace